Responsible decision on North Park — what's next? | Opinion

NOTE: This guest column article featuring President & CEO Eric Spoonmore, was originally published by The Herald-Times on Friday, November 28th, 2025.

On Nov. 3, the Monroe County Council voted to reject the purchase of the North Park property between Bloomington and Ellettsville to construct a $230 million justice complex. The project included a new jail and sheriff’s department, nine new courtrooms with accompanying judges’ chambers and new offices for the prosecutor’s staff, county clerk’s staff and the public defender’s office.
​
While the proposal for North Park failed, one fact remains: County officials remain committed to the urgent need for, at minimum, a new jail. The existing facility is inadequate and no longer meets modern operational standards. A safe, humane, and functional jail is a critical component of a forward-looking justice system. Fortunately, there are viable and accessible sites near Bloomington where the county can construct a new facility that better reflects our community’s values. And while the jail itself does not need to be located downtown, all other justice-related services absolutely should remain there.

​This moment offers an opportunity for clear goals, transparent planning and collaboration among county leaders, justice stakeholders and the business community. We urge officials to prioritize these considerations:
​

1. Develop a Plan for the future of the Charlotte T. Zietlow Justice Building. If the county intends to relocate the full spectrum of services now housed in the Justice Building, planning must start with a realistic, forward-looking reuse strategy for the property we already own. The current Justice Building is a cornerstone of our community. It houses the nine circuit courts, the prosecutor’s office, and key county clerk functions, including issuing marriage licenses, collecting child support payments, processing traffic violations and managing all court filings. Moving these essential services miles away would uproot the entire Monroe County legal system from the downtown core — harming small businesses, reducing foot traffic and leaving a significant void in our central business district.
2. Protect downtown’s economic vitality. Attorneys, title companies, financial institutions and other professional services rely on proximity to the Justice Building, and their presence, in turn, supports local restaurants, retailers, and service providers. Relocating these legal services would have disrupted the operations of many nearby businesses and drained daily economic activity from downtown. The county council’s vote protected this important ecosystem, and the county’s long-term plan must do the same.
3. Keep justice accessible. The current Justice Building is walkable, transit-accessible and integrated with services that support residents navigating the court system. Any proposal to permanently relocate court services and related functions must account for the transportation barriers that would be created for residents with limited means, disabilities or no personal vehicle. Justice must remain within reach of everyone in Monroe County.
4. Finally — safeguard fiscal health. At a projected $230 million, the proposed North Park complex would have been the largest capital expenditure in Monroe County’s history. Combined with new fiscal constraints imposed by Senate Enrolled Act 1, moving forward would have jeopardized the county’s ability to meet other essential needs—public safety staffing, infrastructure maintenance, housing, and social services. Other Indiana counties have recently constructed new jails for well under $100 million. Local officials should scale back costs accordingly to protect Monroe County’s long-term fiscal health.

The council’s decision to reject the $230 million North Park proposal showed that they are willing to respond to constructive community feedback. But much work remains to reach a more prudent, sustainable solution. The Chamber stands ready to support the next phase of planning and to help ensure an outcome that preserves downtown vitality, protects taxpayers and delivers a justice system that works for everyone. Monroe County now has an opportunity to reset this process — and we must get it right.