Bloomington Chamber of Commerce
  • Membership
    • Business Directory
    • Become a Member
    • Benefits of Membership >
      • Interested in Membership
    • Levels of Membership
    • Member Portal & Materials >
      • Member Login
    • Chamber App
    • Connect Bloomington
    • Member Resources
  • Events & News
    • Signature Events >
      • Community Awards Nominations
      • Educator of the Year Nominations
    • Chamber Events Calendar
    • Sponsorship
    • Member News
    • Multimedia Gallery
    • Chamber News
  • Initiatives & Resources
    • Bloomington Women in Leadership
    • The Success School
    • Young Professionals Bloomington >
      • YPB Steering Committee
    • Business Resources
    • Job Board
    • Community Calendar
  • Advocacy
    • Advocacy Matters Updates
    • Legislative Agenda
    • Local Government
    • Advocacy Resources
  • About Us
    • Contact Our Team
    • Board of Directors
    • Press & Media
Member Login | Join Us!
Member Login | Join Us!

 Advocacy Matters
Local News & Updates

Contemplating New Approaches to Road Funding

2/11/2025

1 Comment

 
Picture
Indiana local governments need almost $1 billion more than they currently receive to maintain and preserve the condition of the roads and bridges (IndyStar). Over 80% of the state revenue for roads comes from fuel taxes. Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) has noted that as cars get more fuel efficient, electric vehicles are becoming more popular, and as the cost of construction materials inflates, INDOT has already lost and will continue to lose revenue. To help combat this loss, the Indiana House of Representatives has introduced House Bill 1461. The bill introduces many ideas to get more funding for road construction and upkeep. The bill introduces ideas such as a new tax on food deliveries and rideshares, instituting more toll roads, and special taxes for Indianapolis (IndyStar). 

A New Tax on Food Deliveries and Rideshares: 
Counties will have the option to administer an extra fee on food delivery in order to funnel a few extra million dollars toward road repairs. An analysis of the bill estimates that if all counties were to adopt this fee in 2026, local road revenue could potentially increase between $150 million and $190 million (IndyStar). The bill exempts smaller businesses making less than $1 million in sales annually, and delivery services or rideshares that facilitate less than $100,000 in transactions the previous year. This bill is really targeted toward deliveries made by companies such as DoorDash and Uber. A spokesperson from DoorDash estimated that if this tax were to be implemented statewide, there would be an additional $28 million paid in taxes, and merchants could lose more than $49 million due to lost business (IndyStar). There have been some worries about the fees affecting those of lower income who have a fixed budget and rely on these services for groceries and to get to work. The author of the bill, Jim Pressel, heard these criticisms but is skeptical that the burden would be that cumbersome compared to the fees already tacked on.  

Institute Toll Roads 
Indiana currently has one toll road in northern Indiana. Former governor Mitch Daniels leased that toll road in 2006 to a private company for almost $4 billion. INDOT could decide to lease a new toll road for another large sum of money, or it could contract with a concessionaire and share revenue. Fiscal analysis projects that tolling could result in an extra $850 million a year in revenue on average and $32 billion over a 22-year period (IndyStar).  The major road funding bill of 2017 (HB 1002) gave INDOT the ability to pursue new toll roads with the approval of the governor and bypassing General Assembly approval. House Bill 1461 would remove two restrictions making it easier to implement toll roads; first, INDOT would not have to do a feasibility study beforehand, and second, if the agency applies for the requisite waiver from the federal government by July 1, it can toll lanes anywhere. Like the tax on food deliveries and rideshares, there have been some critiques. The president of the Indiana Motor Truck Association, Gary Langston, called tolling an “inefficient and inaccurate process” compared to fuel taxes and predicted the administrative costs to be higher. (IndyStar). Langston argued that these tolls would hurt the trucking industry as fuel-efficient trucks are not near being commercially available. He argued that the main proponents of tolling discuss how it is important to make all who use the roads pay for them and that fuel is going away, but none of those factors apply to the trucking industry. On the other hand, some argue that the benefit of tolling is to help Indiana reap the benefits of drawing out-of-state workers and travelers and it is important that they pay their fair share.

There has been some research done on the tolling and its affordability when it comes to people experiencing low-income or economically disadvantaged groups. There has been a study done by the
Oregon Toll Program that had some important takeaways such as the fact that tolls could be a more equitable way of funding transportation. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) has said that without tolls, the costs of providing peak-period highway service are borne by more people than those who are using the highway. Tolls can be less burdensome to low-income drivers than systems that are based on taxes, such as car-registration tax, sales tax, and fuel tax. This is because many low-income drivers, for example, drive older vehicles that are not as fuel-efficient as newer models and pay higher fuel taxes for each mile driven. Another important takeaway that the study discussed was that people of all incomes travel at all times, but the research suggests that middle- and higher-income people are more likely to travel at the busiest times and thus are more likely to pay tolls. There are also concerns discussed in the study such as the impact on workers who are receiving lower pay, the barrier of electronic payment, and the cost and process to obtain a transponder. Tolls may make it difficult or too expensive for lower income workers to get to their jobs. Most entry level jobs may have readily available access to public transit, and even if there are those transit services, work hours are during off-peak times, making public transit use less appealing as an option. Not to mention, many low wage workers need to drive to retain their jobs.

There have been
efforts by other departments of transportation such as the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) to establish income-based tolls. The next concern with barriers to electronic payment is that tolls rely on cashless electronic payments. There are some households that do not have credit cards, bank accounts, or cannot afford large deposits so that they may not be able to set up toll accounts, which may limit their use. To combat this, toll facilities are offering cash options for payments. Finally, the cost and process of obtaining a transponder can be a barrier. Most tolled facilities that use electronic toll collection offers discounts to those who register and use transponders. This is to encourage people to join into the system and lower the cost to monitor and enforce toll fees. However, for low-income drivers, the cost to purchase a transponder and pay monthly fees to maintain it can be a barrier. Additionally, distrust of the department of transportation and government systems can be a barrier for trust in signing up for an electronic transponder that follows where people drive. To address the financial impact on people and workers who are experiencing low-income, toll programs offer credits and rebates such as waving the monthly registration fees, free transponders, and credits for a certain number of trips taken per month. Many also argue that the administrative costs will outweigh the revenue gained from the tolls. There have been some tolls that are successful and generate revenue, while there are some that struggle to break even. Federal policy encourages the use of tolling to attract private investors into highway and bridge construction, but numerous private toll roads have been financial failures. The administrative costs of toll collection are much higher than the cost of fuel tax collection
. According to a CBS report, even with extensive use of electronic tolling, collecting highway tolls cost between 8% and 13% of the amount collected.  
​
Special Taxes for Indianapolis:  
House Bill 1461 would give Indianapolis the option to put a referendum question to Marion County voters on whether to raise property tax to pay for road work. This bill would also triple the size of the wheel and excise taxes that Marion County could choose to levy on those who register vehicles in the county. The city is open to the idea of the property tax referendum but is opposed to increasing its wheel and excise taxes.  
All of these are just ideas in order to fill the funding gap to maintain and improve roads in Indiana. These all have their advantages and their critiques that need to be worked out.  As of right now, the bill has had a first reading and has been referred to the Committee on Roads and Transportation. House Bill 1461 is just one of many bills that the Chamber is following right now.  

1 Comment
Allan Buhr
2/19/2025 04:57:09 am

Any tax charged for road repairs should be attached to the vehicle, not the fuel. Electric vehicles use the road, but don't pay the fuel taxes. Seems like adjusting the excise tax on the electric vehicle could make up some of the difference. I don't like toll roads because the people who pay the tolls don't benefit, as the funds are used elsewhere. I would love to see an audit of how the money is spent. I would bet that there is a lot of waste, unnecessary regulations and excessive permit requirements.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Sign Up for our Newsletter
    Categories

    Categories

    All
    Advisory Boards/Commissions
    Affordability
    Annexation
    Arts & Culture
    Awards
    Bloomington Government
    Bloomington IU Relations
    Bloomington-IU Relations
    Bloomington Police
    Broadband
    Budget
    Census
    Chamber Events
    Chamber News
    Civic Engagement
    Climate Change
    Convention Center
    COVID 19 Pandemic
    COVID-19 Pandemic
    Criminal Justice
    Development
    Diversity
    Downtown Bloomington
    Economic Development
    Economic Impact
    Education
    Elections
    Ellettsville
    Emergency Management
    Entrepreneurs
    Environment
    Farmers Market
    Federal Government
    Finance
    Grants
    Historic Preservation
    Homelessness
    Housing
    Indiana University
    Infrastructure
    IN State Government
    IN State Legislature
    Ivy Tech
    Jail
    Judicial
    Law Enforcement
    Low Income Issues
    Major Employers
    Manufacturing
    Minority Business
    Monroe County Circuit Court
    Monroe County Community School Corporation
    Monroe County Government
    Monroe County Public Library
    Networking
    Nonprofits
    Opinion
    Parking
    Parks
    Planning
    Public Art
    Public Health
    Public Policy
    Public Safety
    Quality Of Place
    Quotable Quotes
    Redistricting
    Restaurants
    Richland Bean Blossom Community School Corp.
    Richland-Bean Blossom Community School Corp.
    Rural Communities
    Small Business
    Small Business Development Center
    Startups
    Surveys
    Sustainability
    Taxes
    Technology
    TIF (Tax Increment Financing)
    Tourism
    Transportation
    UDO (Unified Development Ordinance)
    Utilities
    Workforce Attraction/Retention
    Workforce Development
    Youth
    Zoning

    Archives

    Archives

    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    July 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019

    RSS Feed

    Disclaimer

    This blog post reflects the position of the Greater Bloomington Chamber of Commerce, with added insights and commentary from the individual contributor. Opinions expressed are informed by the Chamber’s mission but may include personal perspective.

Contact Our Team | Business Directory

Our Chamber

​The Greater Bloomington Chamber of Commerce provides leadership through member engagement, business advocacy and civic partnerships to strengthen our community and business environment.

Main Contact

421 W 6th Street, Suite A | Bloomington, IN 47404
[email protected]
(812) 336-6381

Office Hours:
Monday-Thursday: 9:00am - 500:pm
Friday: 9:00am - 3:00pm
Trust Center
​
Media Center
Speaking Requests

There is a no refund policy for events.  If you need to reassign your ticket to another person we will be happy to update our attendance list. Thank you.

Chamber Info

About Us
Board of Directors
Contact Our Team

Chamber Resources

Business Directory
Chamber Events Calendar
Member News
Chamber News
Membership Application
Member Login
Business Resources
Picture
Copyright The Greater Bloomington Chamber of Commerce. All Rights Reserved.
  • Membership
    • Business Directory
    • Become a Member
    • Benefits of Membership >
      • Interested in Membership
    • Levels of Membership
    • Member Portal & Materials >
      • Member Login
    • Chamber App
    • Connect Bloomington
    • Member Resources
  • Events & News
    • Signature Events >
      • Community Awards Nominations
      • Educator of the Year Nominations
    • Chamber Events Calendar
    • Sponsorship
    • Member News
    • Multimedia Gallery
    • Chamber News
  • Initiatives & Resources
    • Bloomington Women in Leadership
    • The Success School
    • Young Professionals Bloomington >
      • YPB Steering Committee
    • Business Resources
    • Job Board
    • Community Calendar
  • Advocacy
    • Advocacy Matters Updates
    • Legislative Agenda
    • Local Government
    • Advocacy Resources
  • About Us
    • Contact Our Team
    • Board of Directors
    • Press & Media